Review: From a Low and Quiet Sea

I miiiiight try to read the entire Man Booker longlist this year. I know I won’t finish before the winner is announced, and definitely not before the shortlist is announced, but I’ve never read an entire longlist and I really like the looks of this one. I’ve already read and reviewed Snap and Warlight from the 2018 nominees, and today I’m going to talk about my third read from the longlist, Donal Ryan’s From a Low and Quiet Sea.

fromalowandquietseaAbout the book: Farouk and his family attempt to flee their country when trusting a stranger’s plan for illegal travel becomes a better option than complying with strict religious laws. Lampy struggles with his identity as a fatherless child while staying in his family’s home into his twenties and working (sans-degree) with the elderly. John confesses the sins of his past that may stem from difficulty coping with his brother’s early death. All three men have loss in common, and their unique life paths bring them all together on a cold Irish road one winter evening.

“What’s in the past can’t be changed and what’s to come can’t be known and you can’t give your life to worrying. Sure you can’t. All you have to do is be kind and you’ll have lived a good life.”

There are some fantastic quotes in this book, but don’t be fooled by a moment’s uplifting tone: From a Low and Quiet Sea is a devastating story of little redemption, and the only humor you’ll find within is fleeting or bitter. These are characters struck down by tragedy that breaks them, turns them cruel, or leaves them twisting helplessly beneath the weight of pain they can hardly bear. There is no sentimentality, but there is a constant need for healing and forgiveness driving this story that makes this book perfect fodder for binge-reading. The very first section sets the reader on a path of unstoppable destruction that never tears away the hope of resolution, of a better future. The reader wants Farouk to escape– and reads the entire novel searching for a way out, for all of them.

But it’s best to go into this book with as little knowledge of content as possible, so let’s talk more about the format of this “novel.” From a Low and Quiet Sea is divided into four sections, each told from the perspective of a different man (though the previous perspectives do come back into play at the end of the fourth section). The first three parts take up exactly 50 pages each, which is a symmetry that I rarely see in novels and that always impresses me– it takes a poetic skill to fit everything important, and only what is important, into a particular length of writing (though Lampy’s section seemed a bit longer than necessary to me). But as impressive and interesting as this format is, I’m tempted to call From a Low and Quiet Sea a series of connected short stories rather than a novel.

In theory, I do like books with untraditional formats. There’re even interesting structural elements within each of the character sections here– Farouk’s format is very much a plot-heavy chronological timeline, interspersed with a few crucial made-up stories from his life. Lampy’s section alternates between introspection about his past and the events of a single, important day in his present. John’s section focuses entirely on his past, in the form of a sin-by-sin confession. But my struggle with the format of this book was that the very first section was a strong favorite for me– and, I suspect, will be for most; after that section ended, I knew I was just reading the others to get to the end to see how it all came together. I did not care about Lampy and John’s stories as much as I had Farouk’s. Lampy’s was by far the least propulsive for me, though John’s also left me confused– I thought I had found a connection between John and Farouk’s stories that I would have loved, but by the time John’s section ended I still wasn’t entirely sure whether that connection existed in the novel, or only in my mind.

What I did love undisputedly was Ryan’s writing. The prose is beautiful without verging on ornate, every character feels distinct and real, and none of the events feel forced or constructed to fit a flimsy plot. The lack of quotations around dialogue keeps the story flowing smoothly, the past fitting seamlessly with the present, and characters’ thoughts float naturally into actions. Ryan is in full control of his language.

“If you say something enough times, the repetition makes it true. Any notion you like, no matter how mad it seems, can be a fact’s chrysalis. Once you say it loud enough and often enough it becomes debatable. Debates change minds. Debate is the larval stage of truth. Constant, unflagging, loud repetition completes your notion’s metamorphosis to fact. The fact takes wing and flutters from place to place and mind to mind and makes a living, permanent thing of itself.”

My reaction: 4 out of 5 stars. This was a fast and beautiful read, and I’ll definitely be reading more from this author, starting with All We Shall Know, which has been waiting on my TBR for quite a while now. I also found that there was an interesting similarity between a detail at the end of From a Low and Quiet Sea and at the end of Warlight, my last Man Booker read, though in Warlight this detail made me incredibly sad and in From a Low and Quiet Sea it delighted me. The only real delight I had while reading this book, actually. This was by far my favorite of the three Man Booker 2018 selections I had read at the time, although now that I’ve read a fourth I have a new favorite. That review will be up tomorrow!

Which titles do you plan to read from the Man Booker longlist this year?


The Literary Elephant


22 thoughts on “Review: From a Low and Quiet Sea”

  1. Great review: this sounds fascinating, in spite of the first section being stronger than the others! Depending on when I focus on fiction this year, I might wind up reading just the titles on the shortlist, or I might read this, along with Everything Under and The Mars Room. Curious to see which one on the longlist you enjoyed more than this, though!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you! This is a great read, I do highly recommend it. The title I liked more than this one was Everything Under, so I think you’ve made a good choice there, as well! I’ve seen plenty of reviews that haven’t favored the magical realism aspect of Everything Under, but it was to my taste so I really enjoyed it. I haven’t read The Mars Room yet, but that’s next for me. I’m not sure how many more I’ll get to before the shortlist announcement, but that should definitely help me prioritize. I hope you enjoy whichever titles you end up picking up- they all look really interesting this year, for sure!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. YES so glad you enjoyed this! I completely agree that Farouk’s section was far and away the strongest so unfortunately the whole thing was a bit more unbalanced than I’d have liked, but I found there to be so many striking moments in the other two chapters as well, and the way it all came together I thought was brilliant. And Donal Ryan’s prose is just flawless. I’m so excited that you’re thinking of reading the longlist! Can’t wait to compare notes!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Agreed! Donal Ryan’s writing is absolutely gorgeous. I think I actually marked the most quotes in Lampy’s section even though that was my least favorite section story-wise. Lampy’s section also had the greatest pay off in the end for me; it seemed like nothing was happening in that part, but once I knew the ending I had a lot more appreciation for it, whereas Farouk’s and John’s stories felt more like backstory that stood pretty well on their own. The sense of disconnect between the first three sections was really the only thing that held me back from a 5-star review.

      I really hope I can make it through the whole longlist! I know there are a few titles I’m still waiting for better availability for, but I think I’m up to the challenge. Your reviews have been really encouraging for me so far, I’m definitely enjoying your jaunt through the longlist as well!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I really need to get more in the habit of writing in my books, there are so many lines I’d highlight in his novels! That’s a good point about Lampy’s section… it just felt like a bit of a letdown after the mastery that was Farouk’s chapter. I’ve been reading a lot of reviews of this book and I think John tends to be the most unpopular section, but I actually really enjoyed that one. The sentence by sentence writing maybe wasn’t as brilliant, but I really enjoyed his character arc.

        I’m having a lot of fun with the longlist so I hope you do too! I haven’t given anything 5 stars yet, From a Low and Quiet Sea probably comes closest with 4.5, but so far everything has been 4 stars with the exception of Snap, so at least so far it’s been a really solid list for me.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. I use post-it tabs; I love the idea of annotating but I hate the way my handwriting looks in books.
        I also felt that my expectations were high after Farouk’s section, and Lampy’s didn’t meet them. I would say Lampy’s was the lowest point for me, despite liking a lot more single lines there. But I did like John’s confessions, his honesty and regret in that format were the only reasons I felt at all bad about what happened after finding out how callous and cruel he’d been for most of his adult life. I would agree that he’s a fascinating character.

        I did give Everything Under 5 stars, but I know I lean a little more toward the bizarre and unrealistic than the average reader. (If we can say such a reader exists.) I’ve seen a lot of that across the board though, not a ton of 5-star favorites but nothing really damning either. I’ve had two 3-stars out of four books now, but even in those I found certain aspects of them intriguing and was glad to have read them. I would definitely rather read a list that’s solid as a whole than one with a lot of extreme highs and lows. I would never make it through a list that I expected to find extreme lows in.

        Liked by 1 person

      3. I thought Everything Under was brilliant but unfortunately I just don’t get on with magical realism so that ending dropped it down to 4 for me, but yes, I’m glad you loved it and can’t wait to read your review! I tend to love weirdness in fiction too, but I’d describe my preferred brand of weirdness as something like The Vegetarian, weird but not magical-weird.

        But yes, I’m glad it’s such a solid list so far and I don’t see anything being below Snap in my final rankings so I’m looking forward to the 6.5 books I have left!

        Liked by 1 person

      4. Ah, you’ve reached the halfway point! That’s exciting. I’m definitely looking forward to seeing your thoughts on In Our Mad and Furious City, that’s one of my most-anticipated from the longlist. About 2/3 of the longlist is most-anticipated this year for me though, to be honest. That was how I decided I might as well read them all. I hope the second half of the list goes as well for you as the first!

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s